Welding: time to adapt and change
01 November 2011
Traditional ac welding users have proved reluctant to embrace the concept of adaptive welding but, with industry facing relentless cost reduction pressures, that could be about to change, says David Halford
Adaptive welding remains a small proportion of the UK’s welding market, but its ability to improve the quality of weld and drive cost out of the manufacturing process could offer many manufacturers an alternative to traditional methods.
AC resistance spot welding is still used in many of the UK’s more sophisticated manufacturing processes, most particularly in any metal sheet joining processes; examples include radiator and wire mesh manufacture. It is also still widely used in the automotive manufacturing process.
However, as resistance spot welding users will know, the process is prone to weld disturbance. This can include shunting, caused by alternative current paths leading to a loss of energy, bad fitting of sheets and also variations of coating and sheet thickness.
Problems can also include deterioration in the condition of welding tips, inclusion of sealer and adhesives between the material, and problems attributable to wear of pneumatic cylinders, creating a variation in weld force that subsequently affects weld condition. What’s more, the issues surrounding resistance spot welding do not stop once the process is complete. Quality checking is problematic and relies on two methods.
Firstly, there’s the ultrasonic inspection method, which uses a hand-held probe device that emits ultrasonic waves to ascertain the size of the weld “nugget”. However, the manual nature of the job can mean that individual operators obtain different results from the same weld. The ultrasonic wave method is a highly skilled task that demands trained operators and a separate weld station, all of which adds cost to the process.
The second quality check method is to take a proportion of the finished welds and manually open them up. However, this method will only test selected spot welds and will not illustrate fully the quality of the weld. But, of course, this method will result in an increase in scrapped parts, which will inevitably be generated during the quality checking process.
The setting of weld parameters is crucial in obtaining a ‘good’ weld. Too much energy creates weld ‘splash’, whilst too little may likely lead to a weld ‘failure’. Whilst disturbances during the weld can easily create a ‘splash’ the big fear for many users of resistance spot welding is going into the failure zone which, more often than not, will result in the recall of parts.
The adaptive system can assist in the setting of weld parameters by giving far greater visibility to the identification of programs that cause ‘splash’. It also allows for the setting of cooler weld conditions, with the operator being confident that if disturbances to the weld process do occur, the regulator will adapt accordingly, thus preventing any weld failure. A further benefit is that the initial cooler weld parameters use a lower heat with less energy consumed, which results in a production cost saving.
For the reasons outlined, there is a slow but steady conversion to resistance spot welding adaptive systems which have the ability to correct many of the weld disturbances, during the course of the welding process.
An adaptive welding system has the potential to offer far more control over a production process as it monitors the in-process condition of the weld in millisecond intervals. This monitoring compensates for process disturbances by adjusting the current and, if applicable, the weld time. These adjustments optimise the weld process to ensure the correct energy is applied to all of the welds, which in turn will mean that the correct size weld “nugget” is achieved.
The vital component of an adaptive welding system is the UI regulator (where U = voltage and I = current). The regulator takes inputs from either the primary or secondary current, as well as a voltage tap on the electrodes. Dynamic resistance during the weld is calculated from the sensed current and voltage.
The UI regulator compares the values for the actual and reference resistance every millisecond. If there are differences then the regulator adjusts the weld current accordingly. For example, when the actual resistance is greater than the reference value the weld current will be reduced.
At the end of the programmed weld time the regulator compares the weld energy with the energy for the reference weld and, if necessary, the time may be increased. The regulator ensures that the same amount of energy that was required to create the reference weld is applied for all subsequent welds.
Another key benefit is that a warning or error message can be communicated when a process limit has been exceeded. The process can be halted until a technician or engineer intervenes to check the cause of the disturbance. The system also allows for the production of documentation from process data allowing for greater traceability of welded parts. The system displays all the process-critical parameters online in a diagram, enabling accurate visualisation of the process.
Additional benefits also include a reduction in post-weld checks and a reduction in the number of test parts and the time required to check the weld condition. In turn, this reduces production time and cuts the number of personnel required at the manufacturing site.
Early adopters have embraced adaptive welding as a method of ensuring good quality and driving cost out of the welding process, but it remains a small proportion of the total market.
However, it is becoming increasingly clear that relentless production cost pressures are moving the market in the direction of adaptive welding, particularly amongst users of medium frequency (MFDC) welding who are able to retrofit an adaptive welding module into their existing MFDC weld controller.
This method ensures that the cost of utilising an adaptive welding system is significantly reduced and there is less new technology to incorporate into existing processes.
David Halford is welding product manager at Bosch Rexroth.
Contact Details and Archive...